Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Another successful serious topic


I'm fat and nobody likes me

Status: Offline
Posts: 8440
Date:
Another successful serious topic


GO

__________________
4176_72679264115_502169115_1632781_7399058_n.jpg


Only in cartoons

Status: Offline
Posts: 4655
Date:

'Fraid it doesn't work that way.

__________________
Jason: a demanding lover
Jasno: a lover in demand


I'm fat and nobody likes me

Status: Offline
Posts: 8440
Date:

I COME UP WITH THESE GREAT IDEAS AND YOU **** ALL OVER THEM

YOU ****ING BITCH. ALWAYS NAYSAYING EVERYTHING I CREATE.

__________________
4176_72679264115_502169115_1632781_7399058_n.jpg


Spaghetti

Status: Offline
Posts: 1555
Date:

What are you guys views on abstract objects?

__________________

"grooved stick and handle, for easy riding"



Only in cartoons

Status: Offline
Posts: 4655
Date:

What is an abstract object?

__________________
Jason: a demanding lover
Jasno: a lover in demand


Spaghetti

Status: Offline
Posts: 1555
Date:

Sorry, that was poorly phrased.
What I was interested in, is do you accept the reality of objects such as numbers that exist outside of space and time, or do you believe that any such apparent objects are really nominal constructions from actual, concrete occurences?

__________________

"grooved stick and handle, for easy riding"



Spaghetti

Status: Offline
Posts: 1555
Date:

Personally, I feel driven to accept their existence, largely from considerations relating to the objectivity and necessity of mathematics, yet I can't help but feel they cause a bigger problem for materialism that is usually acknowledged - especially considering the comparative energy that is devoted to issues like the mind-body problem which I feel have more obvious solutions.

__________________

"grooved stick and handle, for easy riding"



Spaghetti

Status: Offline
Posts: 1555
Date:

(Apologies for all the jargon terms)

__________________

"grooved stick and handle, for easy riding"



Only in cartoons

Status: Offline
Posts: 4655
Date:

Numbers exist, but not as objects. I don't think numbers exist outside of mind; numbers of things exist, but the number itself is an abstraction created only through conceptualization, which is a mind-dependent process. Numbers are only as real as any other idea.

__________________
Jason: a demanding lover
Jasno: a lover in demand


Spaghetti

Status: Offline
Posts: 1555
Date:

Thanks. That is kind of the view that I've always wanted to embrace, but - you don't worry that it risks making mathematics seem subjective? A lot of people historically have, like Frege for example.

__________________

"grooved stick and handle, for easy riding"



I'm fat and nobody likes me

Status: Offline
Posts: 8440
Date:

Numbers exist, of course. Of course not as objects, just as measurements of length exist, but there is obviously length.

__________________
4176_72679264115_502169115_1632781_7399058_n.jpg


Spaghetti

Status: Offline
Posts: 1555
Date:

Maybe I'm making a big deal about nothing. It's just one of those things that have struck me.

__________________

"grooved stick and handle, for easy riding"



I'm fat and nobody likes me

Status: Offline
Posts: 8440
Date:

Some people don't believe they exist, or that there are actual numbers.

__________________
4176_72679264115_502169115_1632781_7399058_n.jpg


Spaghetti

Status: Offline
Posts: 1555
Date:

This article covers the topic quite nicely, and perhaps shows better than I can why it is a matter for debate:

http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/abstract-objects/


__________________

"grooved stick and handle, for easy riding"



Only in cartoons

Status: Offline
Posts: 4655
Date:

I do think mathematics is all in our heads and is in that way subjective, but the truths therein are universal and are in no way subject to whims or personal fancies. If we agree on the terms, we will all independently come to the same conclusions (if we're doing it right!) even though the abstract objects we're dealing with exist only in our subjective consciousnesses. Subjective doesn't always have to mean arbitrary.

__________________
Jason: a demanding lover
Jasno: a lover in demand


I'm fat and nobody likes me

Status: Offline
Posts: 8440
Date:

Mathematics is not a subjective system.

__________________
4176_72679264115_502169115_1632781_7399058_n.jpg


Only in cartoons

Status: Offline
Posts: 4655
Date:

Care to elaborate on that, considering the qualifications I tacked onto my use of the term?

__________________
Jason: a demanding lover
Jasno: a lover in demand


I'm fat and nobody likes me

Status: Offline
Posts: 8440
Date:

These objects don't exist only in our consciousness, depending on what you mean by " These objects " ( Actual numbers? )


-- Edited by DEATHPIGGIE at 20:46, 2008-08-23

__________________
4176_72679264115_502169115_1632781_7399058_n.jpg


Only in cartoons

Status: Offline
Posts: 4655
Date:

The numbers themselves, yes. They do not exist objectively, even though our understanding of them is gained through observation of discrete entities. So, mathematics -- knowledge concerning relationships between numbers -- is a subjective experience even if the laws therein are universal and absolute.

__________________
Jason: a demanding lover
Jasno: a lover in demand


I'm fat and nobody likes me

Status: Offline
Posts: 8440
Date:

I do not see how something, say something simple like addition, is subjective.

Do you think any human activity is objective?

__________________
4176_72679264115_502169115_1632781_7399058_n.jpg
1 2  >  Last»  | Page of 2  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard