The Prestige vs. The Illusionist

Awkward Smile · Inconsiderate Hardcore Lesbian

The Prestige vs. The Illusionist

DEATHPIGGIE · I'm fat and nobody likes me

I have no clue. They both sound ****.

Pizza · Sheriff of Paddy's

Eeney meeney miney mo...

Awkward Smile · Inconsiderate Hardcore Lesbian

I liked the prestige better.

Ozpunker · Senior Member

I've seen the Illusionist but looking at the cast in the other one. I might like them both.

Jason · Only in cartoons

I didn't watch The Prestige the whole way through because I thought it was boring. Thus, The Illusionist is the winner.

Andy001 · Spaghetti

Why do I never seem to watch any new films?

-insert 'it's not fair' picture-

Awkward Smile · Inconsiderate Hardcore Lesbian

They both came out in 2006.

john31584 · Zinc Saucier

I liked The Prestige better.

They're 2 very different movies, though.

Seacow2 · Member

I kind of liked the Prestige, although the ending was a bit...stupid. Should I see the Illusionist, then? I noticed it doesn't have Cillian Murphy. Points against it right there.

john31584 · Zinc Saucier

Neither does The Prestige.

SlashXLA · Senior Member

The Prestige:
Pros: Scarlett Johansson, Michael Caine, Tesla, a twist that kept me guessing.
Cons: ****ty real magic.

The Illusionist
Pros: Ed Norton, an almost realistic plot line.
Cons: tragically predictable, only spends 30 seconds on the plot twist. Also, I was rooting for the prince.

In conclusion, if you have yet to see these, you're better off watching four hours of porn.